Last week, on Twitter, I mentioned that we were beginning "sleep training" (I hate that term) with Gunner. I've received a few emails asking how it was going and then asking what approach we've used, so here are all of the details.

1) What approach are you using?
We have used the approach described in Ferber's book Solve Your Child's Sleep Problems. Ferber recommends The Progressive-Waiting Approach. He also talks a lot about sleep associations, and this information is something I found extremely valuable. I'll admit at first I was scared of using any recommendations from Ferber because I'd heard so many misconceptions on what he believes. In short terms, The Progressive-Waiting Approach is a "crying it out" technique but Ferber never recommends you letting a child cry for an unlimited amount of time. I know some people see "crying it out" as evil, but this plan gradually uses increasing time amounts for the crying...basically, each night you let them cry a little longer. The longest G ever had to cried before falling asleep was 15 minutes. I am never a fan of letting my child cry, but this approach worked best for Gunner, I won't spend any more time describing the approach but if you'd like more details you are more than welcome to email me.
2) Do you still feed him in the middle of the night?
Yes and no. We learned from Gunner's pediatrician that at this point in time there is no nutritional need for him to eat in the middle of the night; however, we made a personal decision that if he wakes after 5 am, we will feed him. Holding off his feeding has not been a problem at all.
3) Has Gunner's night sleep improved?
Yes,
yes, yes! Now, it took about 3 days to get there but he is now falling
asleep on his own when put down for bed and when he wakes at night. I
really loved rocking my son to sleep at night, but not so much at 3 am.
He also has slept three full nights in a row...asleep at 7:30 pm, awake
at 6:00(ish) am to eat.
4) Has his napping gotten any better?
No, not yet. But we have hope! We decided we would get his night sleeping under control before working on his napping.
All in all, Gunner's sleep has improved remarkably. The past few nights, he has actually whined if I try to cuddle him a little before putting him down. We have a son that badly needed the sleep structure and so we did what was necessary. However, I do want to say that I don't believe that sleep training is for everyone or every baby. I know several babies who have never needed it. Those babies fall asleep easily on their own or don't wake in the night, if you have one of those babies, consider yourself lucky and don't worry much about sleep training. Even if you don't have one of those babies, I'm not saying you have to sleep train. Do what is best for your child, and remember that only you can decide what that is.
If you have any other specific questions, please email me! I'd love to help in any way that I can. texaslovebirds {@} gmail {dot} com.

Yay! I'm so glad you found something that works well for G and your family! I've had a lot of friends who have had success with "ferberizing" (I hate that term).
ReplyDeleteSo sweet. I don't have children, yet, but I am not looking forward to "sleep training" at all. :(
ReplyDeleteYay for sleep! I Ferberized Jacob when he was around 16 months old...he screamed his head off every night for 20-30 minutes for an entire week...but now he can settle himself and also gets mad if I try to cuddle him in the glider. We also tried the "No Cry Sleep Solution for Toddlers" and we kinda use both books for tips and advice. Whatever works lol :) I really wish we'd done it when Jacob was smaller...maybe he would have slept through the night at 6 months instead of 16 months ;)
ReplyDeleteWe did the Baby Sleep Solution for both girls and it's so true - you have a bad night, then a worse night, then a bad night and then it gets better. Stick with it! There is hope!!
ReplyDeleteLB
www.accordingtol.com
we did "sleep training" with Hudson and it has saved our lives. Everyone always tells me how lucky I am for having a baby that sleeps so well, but I always want to say "because I worked my butt off to get it that way!"
ReplyDeleteso glad gunner is doing well!
Sleep training has been proven to be uneffective. You are teaching your child you will not respond to his needs. Not feeding him in the night is cruel.
ReplyDeleteApparently "anonymous" missed the part where you said this has actually been effective for your son. He's your son, you do what's best for him and that's all that matters. I haven't done a whole lot of research on the sleep training thing but I'm definitely intrigued. Violet's sleep was awesome for a few weeks and now she's regressed and we're not sure what to do. Thanks for sharing this and I hope it continues to work for y'all!!
ReplyDelete